[TF Focus] Is 'Eok Rap' an Essential Element or a Hindrance in K-Pop?

Conflicting reactions grow around 'forced rap'Trend of recognizing and enjoying it as a key characteristic of K-popSome tracks on the fourth mini-album 'PULSE,' released by group RESCENE on the 3rd, are polarizing opinions regarding so-called 'forced rap.' The photo shows RESCENE performing 'With' at the media showcase for the release of 'PULSE' held at the Our WON Banking Hall in Blue Square, Yongsan-gu, Seoul on the 3rd. / Reporter Kim Sung-ryeol[THE FACT|Reporter Choi Hyun-jung] 'Forced rap' is once again a hot topic in the K-pop scene.'Forced rap' is an abbreviation of 'forced rap,' a term created to criticize rap parts in K-pop that are forcibly inserted without considering the overall flow or mood of the music. However, recently, voices defending this 'forced rap,' arguing that it would be too bland and dull without it, are growing louder.The most recent example that best illustrates these conflicting reactions to 'forced rap' is the fourth mini-album 'PULSE' by RESCENE, released on the 3rd. This is because after the album's release, debates over the pros and cons of 'forced rap' erupted on social media and online communities.The song most frequently mentioned as having 'forced rap' in the album is track 4, 'MEME.' The rap part that appears around 1 minute and 25 seconds has received considerable support for its opinion that it does not fit well with the overall mood and feels forcibly inserted, hindering the song's flow.Coincidentally, 'MEME' ranks relatively low among the 5 tracks included in 'PULSE' on major music charts, further supporting this assessment of 'forced rap.'Additionally, there are opinions that the rap part in the title track 'With' was unnecessary, as the song emphasizes the vocal melody line. On the other hand, many reactions state that the rap part is not particularly bothersome or strange and is enjoyable, with some arguing that the rap part enhances the 'unique flavor of K-pop.'Here, RESCENE and 'MEME' are just examples, and what is noteworthy is the conflicting reactions surrounding 'forced rap.'As mentioned earlier, 'forced rap' was not originally a term with positive connotations. The reasons for criticizing 'forced rap' are relatively clear. Critics point out that attempts to forcibly insert rap parts often disrupt the song's flow or mood, and that rap parts are inserted simply due to member positions or result in low-quality rap.Recently, videos compiling 'forced rap' have gained significant popularity on YouTube. DAHYUN of group TWICE is considered an authority on 'K-pop forced rap.' / YouTube 'Me' channel captureHowever, as the history of rap parts in K-pop has lengthened, an increasing number of listeners are now consuming this 'forced rap' as a meme or, furthermore, accepting it as an essential element that defines K-pop.In fact, inserting rap parts in the middle of songs in K-pop is a compositional technique with a long tradition, dating back to the first-generation groups, even before the term 'K-pop' emerged. This means that 'K-pop rap parts' have become familiar to people.Of course, a long history and familiarity do not necessarily guarantee high quality. Moreover, no matter how well a rap part is made, if it doesn't fit the main music, the criticism of it being 'forcibly inserted rap' will not disappear.However, recent K-pop fans tend to enjoy this 'forcedness' and 'randomness' of 'forced rap,' viewing it as a 'charm of K-pop.' For instance, the video 'The Taste of Forced Rap (Positive)' compiled and edited by YouTuber 'Me' garnered 1.47 million views within six days of its upload, achieving great popularity.Furthermore, comments on the video include evaluations like 'It's the foundation of K-pop and a seasoning that maximizes the taste of K-pop,' accurately reflecting listeners' perceptions of 'forced rap.'So, how do K-pop producers view this 'forced rap'? As individuals who directly produce and present K-pop groups, they tend to see 'forced rap' not as a matter of preference but as a marketing strategy.A K-pop producer, who requested anonymity, told
, "From a producer's perspective, we need to approach it strategically to create members' characteristics and attractive points. Therefore, rap parts will continue to be included. Also, even if a member's rap is somewhat awkward, their skills improve with consistent rap parts. This is a fact that many groups have proven through experience in the past."He added, "Furthermore, as K-pop globalizes, overseas audiences are increasingly paying attention to K-pop's unique rap parts. There is no reason not to use a method that can promote the charm of the song and its members even a little more."The song 'Dumb Dumb' by group Red Velvet is considered a prime example of the 'charm of forced rap' among K-pop fans. The photo shows Red Velvet performing 'Dumb Dumb' at the '2015 Guro Asia Culture Festival' held at Gocheok Sky Dome, Guro-gu, Seoul on October 31, 2015. / THE FACT DBAdditionally, B, the CEO of a hip-hop label, argued that the term 'forced rap' itself is no longer relevant. B stated, "The time to question whether it's forced or not has passed. Currently, many members in K-pop groups rap better than most rappers. Rap parts are necessary to showcase the talent and abilities of these members."He further commented, "Moreover, the participation of hip-hop musicians as producers in K-pop has significantly increased. I believe rap parts are included because they judge that they can be incorporated without disrupting the song's flow or mood. In that sense, the term 'forced rap' is no longer applicable."B added, "In the past, there was a prejudice that 'members who can't sing do rap,' but this is just a prejudice. Rap and hip-hop have established themselves as the most important genres in popular music, and in the current K-pop system, rap lessons are mandatory. Therefore, K-pop groups possess solid skills even at debut. Of course, there can be differences in the quality of production for each song. However, that is an issue with the song itself, not the rap part. There is no need to view the rap part itself negatively."[Entertainment Department | ssent@tf.co.kr]laugardagr@tf.co.kr