[TF Magnifying Glass] 'Mr. Trot 4' Identity Crisis Amidst Controversy... Resembles the Success Formula of Latecomers

The 'Active VS Inactive' confrontation, reminiscent of MBN's 'Nameless Legend's' 'Famous VS Unknown'From blue and white colors to 'Trot War' slogans... overlapping conceptsTV CHOSUN's 'Mister Trot', which has claimed to be the originator of trot auditions, is embroiled in an unexpected identity controversy as its fourth season approaches, with its new concept overlapping with MBN's 'Nameless Legend 2', a latecomer, in terms of competition format, colors, and promotional slogans. /TVCHOSUN[THE FACT|Reporter Kang Il-hong] TV CHOSUN's 'Mister Trot', which has claimed to be the originator of trot auditions, is embroiled in an unexpected identity controversy as its fourth season approaches. This is due to the new concept, which seems to follow the success formula of latecomers. The original program that pioneered the trot audition market is now in the ironic situation of having to explain its differentiation from later programs.The trot audition craze, which began in earnest with the success of 'Miss Trot' in 2019, peaked with 'Mister Trot' the following year. It expanded the public appeal of trot by producing stars such as Lim Young Woong, Young Tak, and Lee Chan-won, and since then, terrestrial broadcasters, general programming channels, and local broadcasting stations have all rushed to present similar audition programs.It is difficult for completely new ideas to fall from the sky. Creative formats can also emerge in the process of benchmarking existing successful cases. As about seven years have passed, a fierce competition has now formed between the originator and the latecomers.However, the teaser video released by 'Mister Trot 4', which is set to premiere on December 17, is perplexing in many ways. The core concept of this season is 'Active VS Inactive', a format where singers who have already built up their careers and contestants dreaming of a new challenge are divided into two camps for a head-to-head confrontation.The problem is that this format bears a striking resemblance to the 'Famous VS Unknown' confrontation format of MBN's 'Nameless Legend', which recently gained attention. Of course, there is a clear difference in that 'active' and 'inactive' are based on whether they are currently active, while 'famous' and 'unknown' are based on public recognition. However, the competitive structure of dividing contestants into two groups and overturning existing positions with skill gives a similar impression.What is even more eye-catching is the visual direction. Just as 'Nameless Legend' distinguished unknown contestants with blue and famous contestants with white, 'Mister Trot 4' also features active contestants appearing in blue and inactive contestants in white. While the mere use of colors cannot be definitively labeled as imitation, the overlap in both the confrontation format and the symbolic colors is certainly an interesting point of comparison.The promotional slogans are similar. While 'Nameless Legend' prominently featured 'The Rank War of Trot Gentlemen', 'Mister Trot 4' is attracting viewers' attention with the slogan 'Active VS Inactive, the Trot War Begins'. The reason why many are pointing out that it is difficult to dismiss these as mere coincidences is the simultaneous appearance of similar elements, from the way contestants are divided to the color concept and the promotional strategy emphasizing war.In particular, the choice to abandon the strong red color, which had become a symbol of the 'Miss Trot' and 'Mister Trot' series, and to prominently feature blue and white is even more puzzling. Why would the originator, which has built its own brand image and color for nearly seven years, choose a change that evokes a latecomer program?Of course, the attempt to introduce a new competitive format and break the existing mold cannot be faulted. The competition in the audition market has become fierce, and the production team must have had deep considerations. However, change must have its own unique reasons and differentiation. Attempting new things and copying the success formula of competing works are clearly different matters.Ultimately, what matters is what happens after the broadcast. If 'Mister Trot 4' demonstrates its unique narrative and ability to discover new stars in the actual competition, the current controversy may prove to be unfounded. However, if it fails to shake off the impression of following in the footsteps of others, it cannot receive viewers' choices solely based on the title of originator.The pride of an originator must be proven not by past success, but by present differentiation. It remains to be seen whether 'Mister Trot 4' can create a new stage worthy of an originator, beyond changes made out of consideration for latecomers.eel@tf.co.kr