[Kang Il-hong's Issue Talk] Are Trot Auditions Also Copying Each Other? 'Mister Trot 4' and the Crisis of the Original

Park Ji-yoon's male friend's suspicious behavior, Choi Dong-seok wins 30 million won in appealOk Joo-hyun's 'Real Estate Counterattack'... Empty Sinsa-dong Building, Leverage Investment BoomerangAI Composed Song 'Melon No. 1'... Will Creators Disappear and Only Royalties Remain?[THE FACT|Reporter Kang Il-hong] TV Chosun's 'Mr. Trot 4', which has claimed to be the originator of trot auditions, is now embroiled in a peculiar controversy, with some questioning if the originator is now imitating a latecomer.This is because the concept revealed ahead of its first broadcast on December 17th feels somewhat familiar. The core of this season is 'Active vs. Inactive' – a format where singers already active in the industry compete against contestants dreaming of new challenges, divided into two camps. However, this structure bears a striking resemblance to the 'Famous vs. Unknown' competition in MBN's 'Rookie Legend,' which recently gained attention.Dividing contestants into two groups, a competitive structure that overturns existing hierarchies, and even visual direction that distinguishes the camps with blue and white colors – of course, 'active' and 'inactive,' and 'famous' and 'unknown' are distinct concepts. And just because the colors are the same doesn't mean it's plagiarism. However, when multiple elements overlap, not just one or two, it's inevitable for viewers to raise an eyebrow.There's an even greater irony. TV Chosun is the very network that opened the trot audition market with 'Miss Trot' in 2019 and produced stars like Lim Young Woong, Kim Ho Joong, and Lee Chan-won with 'Mr. Trot.' Yet, the originator now appears to be conscious of the success formula of latecomers.Why is this happening? One analysis suggests it's due to the broadcasters' desperate competition for ratings. Trot auditions are no longer a new genre but a proven hit product. Similar programs flood the market every year, and viewer interest is becoming fragmented.As a result, broadcasters are tempted to reassemble proven hit elements from competing programs rather than worrying about new differentiation.This is compounded by scheduling competition. The broadcast schedule is hastily finalized to meet the year-end first broadcast deadline, and if the production preparation period was also tight, there might not have been enough time to refine sufficient planning and differentiation strategies. Ultimately, they may have chosen to borrow a familiar hit formula rather than create a new paradigm.However, if the originator is imitating a latecomer, isn't that itself a warning sign for the brand? The trot audition market is no longer a competition of who started first, but who can create a more fresh story.Viewers no longer get excited by dividing contestants by color and calling it a war. The title of 'originator' also has an expiration date. There's a difference between referencing someone else's success formula and chasing someone else's shadow.Will 'Mr. Trot 4' prove the potential of the originator? Or will it be remembered as a program that followed the path to success paved by latecomers? The pride of the originator must be proven not by past ratings, but by how new it is now.Specific details surrounding the adultery lawsuit between broadcaster Choi Dong-seok and Park Ji-yoon have recently come to light, becoming an issue belatedly. Choi Dong-seok's lawsuit against Park Ji-yoon's male acquaintance resulted in him being awarded 30 million won in damages.What led to the reversal of the lawsuit, which was dismissed in the first trial, in the appellate court? The key lies in the actions of the two individuals during their trip to the United States in November 2022. According to the appellate court's ruling revealed on the 18th, the court noted that Park Ji-yoon and her male acquaintance, identified as Mr. A, stayed at the same hotel during their US trip and spent time in the same room in their pajamas.In particular, the fact that the two watched adult content together also served as a basis for the judgment. The court ruled that for one spouse to hide their trip with someone of the opposite sex from their partner, stay in the same room in pajamas, or watch a movie they themselves would deem pornographic together, constitutes a failure to remain faithful to the marital fidelity obligation.Mr. A's side explained that they stayed in the same hotel room to help Park Ji-yoon with a group purchase product shoot, but the court did not accept this explanation. The court reasoned that if there were no issues between the two, there would be no reason to hide the fact of the trip and their accommodation arrangements.However, there is also an important point. The court did not acknowledge sexual intercourse between the two. This is because civil infidelity does not necessarily require sexual intercourse to be established. On the other hand, the trip to Vietnam in April 2024 was different. At that time, the marital relationship was considered to have already broken down, and it was not recognized as infidelity.Ultimately, the appellate court ordered Mr. A, Park Ji-yoon's male acquaintance, to pay 30 million won in damages to Choi Dong-seok. This ruling, which overturned the first trial's dismissal, was decided not by a simple male-female companionship, but by the circumstances of hiding the trip and specific actions in the same room.◆ Park Ji-yoon's Shocking Revelation: "Choi Dong-seok Had a Relationship with Another Woman During Divorce Proceedings"Broadcaster Park Ji-yoon has made a shocking claim regarding the mutual adultery lawsuits with her ex-husband Choi Dong-seok.On the morning of the 19th, Park Ji-yoon took to her personal social media to mention inferiority complex due to income disparity and issues of excessive jealousy as reasons for leaving the home she shared with Choi Dong-seok.She then revealed a more sensational claim.Park Ji-yoon stated, "A few months later, in the house where the family lived together, Choi Dong-seok had a relationship with another woman while the divorce proceedings were ongoing, and I witnessed them visiting each other's homes with my own eyes."It is reiterated that this is solely Park Ji-yoon's personal claim.However, she explained that the meeting with the other woman might have started after their separation and that she filed an adultery lawsuit to confirm the exact dating period.Nevertheless, the court found it difficult to clearly determine the period of infidelity and did not acknowledge the responsibility of the other woman, and Park Ji-yoon stated that she did not appeal further.As mentioned earlier, Choi Dong-seok was ordered to pay 30 million won in damages in the appellate court for the adultery lawsuit against Park Ji-yoon's acquaintance, Mr. A.Regarding this, Park Ji-yoon also claimed that Choi Dong-seok was aware of the other party's sexual orientation and common-law marriage, expressing her exhaustion with media manipulation.Amid conflicting claims from both sides, public attention is focused on the ongoing legal battles and revelations even after the divorce.Musical star Ok Joo-hyun has encountered an unexpected predicament due to real estate issues. She purchased a penthouse at Hannam The Hill for a staggering 19 billion won, but within half a year of taking ownership, she became embroiled in a controversy over financial difficulties, with a court order for auction and seizure due to tax delinquency.However, there is another place that deserves attention: the building owned by Ok Joo-hyun's side, located in Sinsa-dong, Gangnam-gu. Ok Joo-hyun purchased the old building there for 16 billion won in 2022 through a single-person corporation. She then demolished the existing building and invested over 3 billion won in construction costs to complete a new building with one basement level and four above-ground floors by the end of 2023.The problem arises afterward. Despite the building's sophisticated exterior and ample parking space, it has remained vacant for a long period since its completion. Including the purchase price, construction costs, and acquisition tax, the initial investment alone exceeds 20 billion won. It is known that she initially intended to sell this building to secure funds for the Hannam The Hill purchase, but analyses suggest that the sale is being delayed due to the sluggish commercial real estate market and a lack of buyers.The key here is liquidity. Real estate, even if valued at tens of billions of won, is not an asset that can be converted into cash immediately. If it cannot be rented out, no revenue is generated, and if it cannot be sold, interest on loans and financial costs continue to accumulate. Ultimately, the situation of purchasing at a high price, investing a large sum for new construction, and then being unable to sell at a price the market will accept – this is the boomerang effect of leverage investment.Leverage investment, leverage, means 'lever' in English. Just as a lever moves a heavy object with little force, in finance, it refers to creating a larger investment effect with less equity. It involves increasing capital through bank loans for investment.The lesson from Ok Joo-hyun's case is clear. The real danger in real estate investment is not a lack of assets, but a situation where there are many assets but no immediate cash to repay. The crisis of cash flow hidden behind magnificent buildings and ultra-luxury homes. This is what we should focus on now.AI, artificial intelligence, has become an indispensable companion in our daily lives. AI music, not called by humans or composed by humans, has reached the top of the domestic music charts.AI-generated songs are now entering the mainstream of the music market. The problem is, when a song becomes popular and generates money, who will receive the royalties? In fact, the song 'Have You Become the Adult You Dreamed Of?' by the AI project 'Stay' by the producing team Glorywave, ranked first on the Melon weekly chart in the second week of this month.This is also the first time AI music has reached the top of the Melon real-time Top 100. Currently, generative platforms like SUNO are used for AI music production.The methods vary, from supplementing human-made songs with AI to completing lyrics, composition, and arrangement with just a few commands, to humans creating lyrics and concepts and editing AI outputs to completion. However, the legal system is not keeping pace with the speed of change in the music market.The core issue is copyright. The principle generally recognized domestically and internationally is that purely AI-generated works without human creative contribution are not granted copyright. On the other hand, if humans have made a substantial creative contribution to the creation process, copyright can be recognized for that part.Organizations like ASCAP and BMI in the United States, and JASRAC in Japan, are moving towards managing AI-assisted music with human creative input under certain conditions. However, in Korea, the standards for trust registration and royalty distribution for AI-utilized music are still unclear.Because of this, there are concerns that individuals who do not properly disclose their use of AI may receive royalties, or that a large volume of AI music may be registered, reducing the share for existing music creators. Furthermore, there is the issue of AI infringing on existing music without permission during its learning process. In Germany, the music copyright management organization GEMA won the first trial in a lawsuit filed against SUNO.The challenges to be addressed going forward are clear. First, a standard must be established for how much human creative contribution will be recognized. Second, the use of AI must be transparently disclosed, and principles for royalty collection and distribution must be established.Third, copyright infringement during the AI learning process must be prevented, and music platforms must establish standards for AI music labeling, mass uploads, and prevention of artist impersonation. AI music cannot be unconditionally blocked or unconditionally allowed.What is important is institutional balance that accommodates technological advancements while protecting the rights and fair compensation of human creators. In an era where AI creates songs, it is time for social consensus on who will receive the profits generated by those songs.eel@tf.co.kr